The Right Colour for Light in a Cellar Door

Abstract

The choice of lighting colour in a cellar is crucial for both functionality and sensory perception. This paper examines the optimal lighting conditions for cellar doors, considering international standards and research on light’s impact on perception. ISO 8589 provides guidance on lighting for sensory analysis, recommending cool 6500K light for scientific testing and around 4000K for consumer testing. Additionally, research by Fairchild (2018) and Oberfeld et al. (2009) highlights how light temperature and spectrum influence the perception of wine colour and taste. These insights guide the recommendations for appropriate lighting in cellars.

Introduction

Cellar doors, whether used for wine tasting, tourism, office space, distribution, storage, testing or other purposes, require careful consideration of lighting to ensure functionality and enhance sensory experiences. The colour temperature of light can significantly impact visibility, safety, and the perception of stored items. This paper explores the optimal lighting conditions for cellar doors, drawing from international standards and relevant research.

International Standards for Sensory Analysis

ISO 8589: Sensory analysis – General guidance for the design of test rooms, offers comprehensive guidelines on the optimal conditions for sensory evaluation, including lighting. This standard suggests that cool lighting at 6500K is ideal for scientific testing due to its ability to provide clear, unbiased sensory input. This type of lighting mimics daylight, ensuring that colours and details are perceived accurately, which is crucial for tasks requiring precision, such as quality control and scientific analysis.

For consumer testing, ISO 8589 recommends lighting closer to 4000K. This warmer, yet still neutral, light creates a more comfortable environment that is closer to typical indoor lighting conditions. This setting helps consumers feel at ease, potentially leading to more accurate reflections of their true preferences and perceptions.

The Influence of Light on Wine Perception

Fairchild’s Research on Wine Colours

Research by Fairchild (2018) in “The Colours of Wine” delves into how different lighting conditions affect the perception of wine colour and taste. The study found that the pigments in wine react variably under different light spectrums and temperatures, which can alter the perceived colour and, consequently, the taste experience. This phenomenon is particularly important in wine cellars, where the presentation and sensory qualities of wine are paramount.

Fairchild’s research indicates that the temperature and spectrum of light can enhance or diminish the visibility of certain pigments in wine. For example, under warmer light (around 4000K), red wines may appear richer and more appealing, while cool light (6500K) can provide a more accurate representation of the wine’s true colour, which is essential for scientific evaluation and quality control.

Oberfeld et al.’s Study on Ambient Lighting and Flavour

In a study conducted by Oberfeld et al. (2009), titled “Ambient Lighting Modifies the Flavour of Wine,” it was demonstrated that ambient lighting can significantly alter the perceived flavour of wine. The study revealed that wines tasted under red and blue lighting conditions were perceived differently in terms of flavour intensity and overall enjoyment compared to those tasted under neutral lighting conditions. This suggests that the sensory qualities of wine are not only influenced by its intrinsic properties but also by the external lighting environment.

Guidelines from the OIV

The Organisation Internationale de la Vigne et du Vin (OIV) provides a comprehensive review on the sensory analysis of wine, emphasising the importance of consistent and appropriate lighting conditions in sensory evaluation. The OIV guidelines support the use of neutral lighting (around 4000K) for consumer evaluations to ensure a comfortable and relatable environment for tasters. This approach aligns with the recommendations of ISO 8589 for consumer testing.

Practical Considerations from LightingStyle

According to LightingStyle’s guide to lighting colour temperature, different colour temperatures can create varied atmospheres and affect the functionality of a space. Cooler temperatures (5000K-6500K) are best suited for workspaces requiring high visibility and concentration, while warmer temperatures (2700K-4000K) are ideal for creating cosy and inviting environments. These practical insights are crucial when designing lighting for cellars that may serve multiple purposes.

Recommendations for Cellar door Lighting

Based on ISO 8589, Fairchild’s and Oberfeld et al.’s findings, and practical insights from LightingStyle and the OIV, the following recommendations are proposed for cellar door lighting:

  1. Scientific and Quality Control Purposes:
    • Use cool white light at 6500K. This setting provides a neutral and precise environment that is crucial for accurate sensory evaluation and quality control tasks.
  2. Consumer and Presentation Areas:
    • Opt for neutral white light around 4000K. This lighting condition is more inviting and comfortable for consumers, enhancing the presentation of wines and other items in the cellar. It also helps to ensure that the sensory experience aligns with typical consumer environments, making it easier to gauge consumer preferences.
  3. General Storage and Functionality:
    • Employ a mix of lighting conditions based on the primary use of the cellar. For general storage, where detailed inspection is less critical, a range between 4000K and 5000K can be suitable, providing a balance between functionality and comfort.

Conclusion

The selection of the right colour for light in a cellar door involves balancing scientific precision and consumer comfort. Adhering to the guidelines of ISO 8589 ensures that lighting conditions meet the needs of both scientific and consumer testing. Furthermore, considering the insights from Fairchild’s and Oberfeld et al.’s research on wine perception highlights the importance of light temperature and spectrum in enhancing the sensory experience. By carefully choosing the appropriate lighting, cellar environments can be optimised for both functionality and aesthetic appeal, ultimately improving the overall experience for users.

References

LET'S JUST START WITH A COFFEE

For most tourism businesses, working on your buildings and grounds is a big deal. There is a lot of money and time at stake and can be difficult to know where to start. So let’s just start with a coffee.